Wall’s Wharf: Best Beachfront Dining on Long Island Sound in Bayville, Long Island, NY!


Circa 1916, Pierce Wall had a thriving beach business on the North Shore of LongIsland. Wall’s Baths catered to the beach crowd providing facilities for showers, changing areas, swimming privileges and snack stands. It was a summer favorite for beach goers, with its spectacular view of the Long Island Sound and the Connecticut Coast.

In 1945, Paul J. Reinhardt purchased the business and property. His vision was to create a restaurant with fair prices, good food and beach privileges. He renamed the business Wall’s Beach Restaurant, keeping the name Wall in honor of the first proprietor. In 1946, Paul rebuilt the building with a handful of men, including his brother Ed Reinhardt and his brother-in-law Ralph Murphy. The building was constructed with steel beams with the intention of having a second story, however due to WWII, supplies were limited. The building had to remain one story with a flat roof. Wall’s Beach quickly became a favorite spot, renown for its great seafood, prime steaks, Prime Rib, and of course its magnificent water view.

In 1970, the business was sold to someone outside the family and remained open for approximately six months. In 1971, Paul Reinhardt’s son, Bill, bought back the property and business. His intention has been to create a comfortable atmosphere with a fine dining experience. The name was changed to Wall’s Wharf, affectionately referred to as “The Wharf”, or “Wally’s” by many locals. Beach privileges are no longer permitted, but patrons can still walk along our private beach and enjoy the spectacular view.

Wall’s Wharf takes pride in its fine food and pleasant atmosphere and is a Fred Bollaci Enterprises Preferred Destination for great, fun waterfront dining on the North Shore! Enjoy al fresco in nice weather, and catch the sunset over Long Island Sound!

e9cf01c03f0979eb59cc770a5b87a542 1041a92309a495fbb321890d3db9c32c

Salads, sandwiches, burgers, raw bar, and more! There is something for everyone.

d09a7b61be7109f81eb8b9ace83ab6a1 82c000542cf828ca7c5d80972fb92c63

Spectacular sunsets!


Fantastic location right on the beach, overlooking the Sound.

bcd0049c35799cdf57d06eaf2eb3cff6 0e364cf4a1a53aa0afe4627cbc86d145

Sushi is one of the stars of the show!


Enjoy fresh, local Pine Island Oysters from Oyster Bay!


Wall’s Wharf is an ideal setting for a special occasion or event!




Wall’s Wharf

18 Greenwich Ave.

Bayville, NY


About Fred Bollaci

I'm CEO and President of Fred Bollaci Enterprises. I lost more than 100 pounds while living "La Dolce Vita" and I'm now known as "The Healthy Gourmet." Sample the good life with me through fitness, fine food, and good wine. Meet chefs who cater to a healthy gourmet lifestyle through my Golden Palate blog.
This entry was posted in Fred Bollaci on Dining and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.